Is Fractional Consulting Right for You? A Reality Check for Nonprofit Professionals

Prefer to listen while commuting or preparing dinner? Click here and get access to the Fracture podcast feed. Pause if you need to (or listen at 2x speed) and get all the details/advice that don’t make it to the blog posts.

I want to believe in fractional, but...

That's how the conversation started. A nonprofit professional with 21 years of running organizations reached out because something wasn't adding up about fractional consulting. She'd heard people talking about it everywhere, saw consultants positioning themselves as "fractional," but couldn't reconcile it with everything she knew about running a development operation.

So we had the honest conversation everyone should be having before jumping into fractional work, whether you're thinking about offering it or hiring it.

This isn't about selling you on fractional consulting. This is about giving you the real parameters so you can figure out if this model actually solves your problem.

When Fractional Actually Works (The Reality Check)

Fractional isn't a magic solution for every nonprofit consultant who's tired of their job. It's a very specific answer to a very specific set of circumstances, for both the organizations hiring and the consultants doing the work.

THE ORGANIZATIONS WHERE FRACTIONAL THRIVES:

Organizations face a common dilemma. Their function has outgrown being someone's side project, but they don't have the budget to hire someone with real experience.

So they compromise. They hire a junior person who needs training and development, but they don't have anyone to train them.

That's the problem fractional solves.

You're ready to hire. You have resources to invest. But you can't afford someone with 10+ years of experience, and you don't have capacity to develop someone junior. A fractional consultant gives you strategic expertise and implementation capacity without the full-time salary.

Click on the image to listen to Cindy dig into what “fractional” really means, when fractional fundraising actually works, and the truth about income and expectations in this growing trend.

Perfect for These Nonprofit Consultants

Not every consultant should do fractional work. The model works brilliantly for a specific profile, and it's probably not who you think.

WHO THRIVES AS A FRACTIONAL CONSULTANT:

You've spent years in small nonprofit shops wearing all the hats. You're excellent at both strategy AND day-to-day implementation (and you don't hate the admin work). You're currently making $80K-$90K in-house and want to double your income without managing a team or going to a large institution.

You genuinely love doing the frontline work, not just managing it. You want flexibility more than you want prestige or a massive salary. You're comfortable with boundaries and saying no, or willing to learn fast.

The sweet spot? Someone who's been a director at a small organization. They've done everything. They know how to build systems and they're not afraid to get their hands dirty.

WHO STRUGGLES WITH FRACTIONAL WORK:

If you're coming from a $250K+ role at a major institution, fractional probably isn't your path. You're used to managing people, delegating detailed work, and focusing solely on strategy. That's not fractional.

If you think "fractional" just means flexible hours with consulting work, you're missing the model. If you're not willing to turn down organizations that aren't a good fit, you'll burn out fast. If you want to make $300K+, this isn't your model.

The Income Reality (Bottom Line on Compensation)

Let's talk money because that's where a lot of the confusion lives.

Three fractional clients at an average of $4K per month gets you to $144K annually. No benefits, but also no commute, no office politics, and complete control over your schedule.

If you've been making $80-90K in-house at a small nonprofit, that's a huge jump. Plus you get to work with organizations you choose.

But if you're coming from a major institution making $250K, fractional doesn't make financial sense. The model isn't designed to support that salary level. And that's okay, it's just not the right fit.

Some fractional consultants charge $5K or more per client. Some take on four clients. There's room to grow. But the baseline expectations matter. This isn't the path to $300K unless you build an agency model.

When You Should Say No (The Qualification Question)

Here's what I teach people in my network: you're going to spend more time saying no to organizations than closing deals.

If an organization isn't ready for fractional support, taking their money doesn't serve anyone. You can't help them; they won't see results, and everyone ends up frustrated.

RED FLAGS TO QUALIFY OUT:

They have completely unrealistic expectations. They think fractional means "part-time employee." They're looking for the cheapest option, not the right fit. They want someone to "just do the work" without strategic oversight.

Your job isn't to convince every organization that fractional makes sense. Your job is to find the organizations where fractional actually solves their specific problem.

The Bigger Picture: Who's Calling Themselves "Fractional"?

A lot of people in the nonprofit sector call themselves fractional without understanding the model. They think it's just a fancy way to say "consultant with flexible hours."

That's not fractional.

Fractional means you're filling an executive function at a strategic level while also handling implementation. You're not a project-based consultant. You're not a freelancer doing one-off tasks. You're functioning as an embedded member of the leadership team, just not full-time.

The confusion hurts everyone. Organizations hire "fractional" consultants who don't deliver. Consultants position themselves as fractional when they're really just selling services. And the whole model gets diluted.

If you're going to call yourself fractional, understand what you're actually offering. If you're hiring fractional support, know what you should expect.

Making the Decision

Fractional consulting is brilliant for the right people in the right circumstances. But forcing it when you're not the right fit, either as a consultant or as an organization, creates dysfunction, burnout, and failure.

Better to know now than waste a year figuring it out the hard way.

Ready to build a fractional consulting business the right way?

// The Nonprofit Fractional Operating System teaches you how to find the right clients, set proper boundaries, and build six figures with just three organizations, without the burnout or bullshit. Learn more here.

// In episode 15 of FRACTURE, I broke down why every scope creep problem in your consulting business is actually your responsibility to solve, not your client's. If you're struggling with boundaries and saying no, that episode will give you the exact language and mindset shifts you need.

P.S. Want to hear the full conversation with the fractional skeptic? Listen to the complete Fracture podcast episode here, where we dig into the specific revenue ranges where fractional works, why junior fundraisers keep failing at organizations, and how to know if you're the right consultant profile for this model.

READY TO HEAR WHAT NO ONE ELSE IS SAYING?

Subscribe to Fracture. This private podcast is where we talk honestly about what it takes to build a fractional consulting business that pays you well, respects your time, and still lets you care deeply about your work.